diff --git a/packages/discord.js/src/structures/MessageMentions.js b/packages/discord.js/src/structures/MessageMentions.js
index ca5c720a12f5..6a5acaad772c 100644
--- a/packages/discord.js/src/structures/MessageMentions.js
+++ b/packages/discord.js/src/structures/MessageMentions.js
@@ -215,13 +215,18 @@ class MessageMentions {
     const role = this.guild?.roles.resolve(data);
     const channel = this.client.channels.resolve(data);
 
-    if (!ignoreRepliedUser && this.users.has(this.repliedUser?.id) && this.repliedUser?.id === user?.id) return true;
+    if (!ignoreEveryone && user && this.everyone) return true;
+
+    const userWasRepliedTo = user && this.repliedUser?.id === user.id;
+
+    if (!ignoreRepliedUser && userWasRepliedTo && this.users.has(user.id)) return true;
+
     if (!ignoreDirect) {
-      if (this.users.has(user?.id)) return true;
+      if ((ignoreRepliedUser ? !userWasRepliedTo : true) && this.users.has(user?.id)) return true;
       if (this.roles.has(role?.id)) return true;
       if (this.channels.has(channel?.id)) return true;
     }
-    if (user && !ignoreEveryone && this.everyone) return true;
+
     if (!ignoreRoles) {
       const member = this.guild?.members.resolve(data);
       if (member) {