Authors: Bogdan Brinza, Daniel Libby, Zouhir Chahoud
This document is intended as a starting point for engaging the community and standards bodies in developing collaborative solutions fit for standardization. As the solutions to problems described in this document progress along the standards-track, we will retain this document as an archive and use this section to keep the community up-to-date with the most current standards venue and content location of future work and discussions.
- This document status: Active (CSS primitives for dual screen layouts)
- Expected venue: W3C CSS Working Group
- This document status: ARCHIVED (Window Segments Enumeration JavaScript API)
- Current venue: W3C Second Screen Community Group | webscreens/window-segments |
- Current version: Window Segments Enumeration JavaScript API
- Current venue: W3C Second Screen Community Group | webscreens/window-segments |
Web developers targeting dual-screen and foldable devices want to be able to effectively lay out the content in a window that spans multiple display regions. However, the web platform does not yet provide the necessary primitives for building layouts that are optimized for dual-screen or foldable experiences.
Developers may be able to solve this by taking a hard dependency on a specific device hardware parameters - an approach that is fragile, not scalable, and requires work duplication for each new device.
More specific challenges we've heard from our internal product teams that were exploring building experiences for this emerging classes of devices include:
- Hardware differences: Devices could be seamless (e.g. Samsung Galaxy Fold) or have a seam (e.g. Microsoft Surface Neo, Microsoft Surface Duo or ZTE Axon M). In both cases developers might want to take it into account or intentionally ignore depending on scenario;
- Folding capabilities, state: the fold area could be safe or unsafe region to present content;
- Future-proofing: Ideally developers would want a somewhat stable way to target this class of devices without having to rely on specific device hardware parameters.
Before discussing the solution proposal - let's overview existing proposals that are relevant and applicable to the problem space. As matter of principle we should generally avoid creating redundant concepts if we can reuse existing platform APIs and capabilities.
-
Presentation API is solving the problem of a effective use of a secondary screen and likely won't attempt to solve challenges outlined above that are specific to devices where a window can span separate physical displays. This would likely still be a separate problem for foldables
-
Screen Enumeration API Explainer provides information about the physical screen configuration. Web developers might be able to leverage that on foldables, but would need to do extra effort to correlate that information with window parameters. Some concrete examples on why a special purpose API might be useful in addition to Screen Enumeration:
- Getting adjacency information about spanning window regions to lay out content in several areas in logical way for a device;
- Getting inner window dimensions that account for application frame, OS UI elements, etc.
-
Window Placement API Explainer is useful in multi-window scenarios on multiple screen devices, but does not target scenarios in which the hosting application (i.e. browser) has a single window which spans multiple displays. In this case, the developer may not wish to open new windows - just hints to help lay out things properly and take advantage of the physical partitioning of the available layout space.
Additionally, while not a solution in the same sense, a "[css-media-queries] Foldables support and enablement" issue discusses the problem space and outlines some details and touches upon outlined issues.
A summary of the concepts from the other proposals:
- Display region - The representation of a physical monitor on dual-screen devices or the logical view area seperated by the hinge on foldable devices.
- Screen - the aggregate 2D space occupied by all the connected displays.
In order to enable web developers to build layouts that are optimized for dual-screen and foldable experiences declaratively using CSS, we must consider fundamental assumptions of CSS (i.e. a single contiguous rectangular space for laying out content) and introduce new primitives that -together with existing layout media queries- allow developers to create layouts that react to states where the root viewport spans across multiple display regions.
The first primitive we propose is a CSS media feature to determine whether the website is spanning across two adjacent display regions along with the configuration of those two adjacent display regions (e.g. stacked or aside). The second primitive is a set of user agent-defined environment variables that will help developers calculate the size of each screen region in CSS pixels.
The spanning CSS media feature can be used to test whether the browser window is spanning across multiple display regions.
The spanning media feature value can be one of the following keywords:
- single-fold-vertical
This value matches when the layout viewport is spanning a single fold (two display regions) and the fold posture is vertical.
- single-fold-horizontal
This value matches when the layout viewport is spanning a single fold (two display regions) and the fold posture is horizontal.
- none
This value describes the state of when the browser window is not in spanning mode.
We propose the addition of 6 pre-defined CSS environment variables fold-top, fold-right, fold-bottom, fold-left, fold-width, fold-height. Web developers can utilize those variables to calculate each screen segment size at both landscape and portrait orientations. While the spanning media query guarantees there is only a single hinge and two screen segments, developers must not take a dependency that each screen segment is 50% of the viewport height or width, as that is not always the case (see above example of single-fold-horizontal where portions of the top display are consumed by browser UI).
The values of these variables are CSS pixels, and are relative to the layout viewport (i.e. are in the client coordinates, as defined by CSSOM Views). When evaluated when not in one of the spanning states, these values will be treated as if they don't exist, and use the fallback value as passed to the env() function.
This proposal is not meant to solve the problem for foldable devices with more than two screens, due to the unavailability of a CSS construct that allows authors to iterate over a set of values. In this case, an author would need a function that allows them to retrieve the browser's predefined env() variables of the n-th fold/hinge.
The proposed CSS constructs are not currently meant to map to spanning configurations in window managers that allow arbitrary window placement. When windows are spanned across external monitors, it is not clear that there is user intent that applications should split their view over the gap between the physical monitors. Additionally, these values would change as the user moves the window. However, if a valid use case presents itself, it's something we can certainly reconsider.
- Feb 26, 2020: 🚚📦 Window Segments Enumeration JavaScript API has now moved to the W3C Second Screen Community Group. For the explainer, issues, and comments please refer to the webscreens/window-segments GitHub repo.
The CSS constructs and the JavaScript API will be available in iframe context but disabled by default for privacy and security considerations. An author may enable them using the screen-spanning policy; a new feature policy we are proposing that will enable authors to selectively enable the previously mentioned CSS and JavaScript constructs in iframe context. When disabled, getWindowSegments will return a single segment the size of the iframe's viewport, and the CSS environment variables will be treated as unset, and use the fallback values.
iframes where screen-spanning feature policy is enabled will receive values in the client coordinates of the top most window, and it's possible the iframe won't be able to interpret that data without other information from its embedder. As an example, for cross origin iframes, the iframe's embedder must provide information about how to transform from the root client coordinate space to the iframe's client coordinate space, as this information is not available to cross-origin iframes for security reasons.
Let's take a look at a few practical examples of the scenarios above and how window segments would allow to resolve them for better user experience. In each case we'll start with some existing scenario and complicate it to provide opportunity to apply the proposal.
@media (spanning: single-fold-vertical) {
body {
flex-direction: row;
}
.map {
flex: 1 1 env(fold-left)
}
.locations-list {
flex: 1;
}
}const screenSegments = window.getWindowSegments();
if( screenSegments.length > 1 ) {
// now we know the device is a foldable
// it's recommended to test whether screenSegments[0].width === screenSegments[1].width
// and we can update CSS classes in our layout as appropriate
document.body.classList.add('is-foldable');
document.querySelector('.map').classList.add('flex-one-half');
document.querySelector('.locations-list').classList.add('flex-one-half');
}
@media (spanning: none) and (max-width: 728px) {
body {
flex-direction: column;
}
.map {
flex: 0 0 300px;
}
.locations-list {
flex: 1;
}
}window.onresize = function() {
const segments = window.getWindowSegments();
console.log(segments.length) // 1
}
This is an illustrative example that demonstrates how to use the new enviroment variables to position content relative to the fold.
Box 1 .blue and Box 4 .green have a width and height of 100px, however, the requirement for Box 2 .yellow and Box 3 .pink is to fill the screen segment width and have a height of 100px
@media (spanning: single-fold-vertical) {
.blue {
height: 100px;
width: 100px;
position: absolute;
left: calc(env(fold-left) - 100px);
top: 0;
}
.yellow {
height: 100px;
width: calc(100vw - env(fold-right));
position: absolute;
left: env(fold-right);
top: 0;
}
.pink {
height: 100px;
width: env(fold-left);
position: absolute;
left: 0;
bottom: 0;
}
.green {
height: 100px;
width: 100px;
position: absolute;
left: env(fold-right);
bottom: 0;
}
}
[dir="ltr"] .col {
flex: 0 0 env(fold-left);
}
[dir="rtl"] .col {
flex: 0 0 env(fold-right);
}