jasmine option "Stop execution on spec failure" does not work properly in combination with karma

[maximedupre]

Environment

• Jasmine core : v3.1.0
• karma-jasmine: v1.1.2
• Chrome 69
• Operating System and version (desktop or mobile): OSX 10.13.6

Please see jasmine/jasmine#1576

[johnjbarton]

I guess this will be fixed by #224

[DirkToewe]

Is there any update on this? stopSpecOnExpectationFailure: true is not working for me with jasmine-core@3.3.0 and karma-jasmine@2.0.1. I've also tried oneFailurePerSpec: true, throwOnExpectationFailure: true and failFast: true.

Edit1: Adding jasmineEnv.configure({ oneFailurePerSpec: true }) to createSpecFilter() in adapter.js seems to work.

Edit2: It seems like oneFailurePerSpec: true has to be set, before boot.js is executed. Is there a particular reason for calling jasmineEnv.configure(jasmineConfig) once and not before __karma__.start() is called?

[johnjbarton]

Please run karma with --log-level debug or the equivalent config file value. Check the 'final' config. It should contain 'clientConfig' with oneFailurePerSpec. That value will be sent to jasmine when the start function is created: https://github.com/karma-runner/karma-jasmine/blob/master/src/adapter.js#L366

[DirkToewe]

I had already done that ... kind of ... using console.log inside of karma-jasmine's createStartFn. But just to be sure here's the debug output (prettified):

// ...
{
   "random":true,
   "oneFailurePerSpec":true,
   "failFast":true,
   "timeoutInterval":3600000
}
// ...

I am fairly certain that the config is correct because if I change createStartFn from:

function createStartFn (karma, jasmineEnv) {
  return function () {
    var clientConfig = karma.config || {}
    var jasmineConfig = clientConfig.jasmine || {}
    jasmineEnv = jasmineEnv || window.jasmine.getEnv()
    jasmineEnv.configure(jasmineConfig)
    window.jasmine.DEFAULT_TIMEOUT_INTERVAL = jasmineConfig.timeoutInterval ||
       window.jasmine.DEFAULT_TIMEOUT_INTERVAL
    jasmineEnv.addReporter(new KarmaReporter(karma, jasmineEnv))
    jasmineEnv.execute()
  }
}

to:

function createStartFn (karma, jasmineEnv) {
  var clientConfig = karma.config || {}
  var jasmineConfig = clientConfig.jasmine || {}
  jasmineEnv = jasmineEnv || window.jasmine.getEnv()
  jasmineEnv.configure(jasmineConfig)
  window.jasmine.DEFAULT_TIMEOUT_INTERVAL = jasmineConfig.timeoutInterval ||
     window.jasmine.DEFAULT_TIMEOUT_INTERVAL

  return function () {
    jasmineEnv.addReporter(new KarmaReporter(karma, jasmineEnv))
    jasmineEnv.execute()
  }
}

The behavior is according to oneFailurePerSpec: true. The prior implentation of createStartFn() only calls jasmineEnv.configure(jasmineConfig) as soon as __karma__.start() is called not before boot.js is executed.

[johnjbarton]

Ok thanks. Seems like an unfortunate design here: critical parts of the execution sequence move between two files.

I don't see anything in boot.js that could not be done directly in adapter.js more clearly.

Here is what I would do:

1. Remove src/adapter.js, adapter.wrapper and build code.
2. Place the content of boot.js in to lib/adapter.js.
3. Create a new function configureJasmine(karma, jasmineEnv) with the body of your createStartFn() and call it before the call to createStartFn().
4. createStartFn() would just be the return you have.

We can start with just 3 and 4.

[DirkToewe]

Okay. I'm gonna file a PR about 3 & 4 as soon as I get to it.

[johnjbarton]

I believe this issue is fixed in karma-jasmine 2.x. Please reopen if you still see it.

[maximedupre]

Please reopen as it has not been fixed.

[dickinr]

These changes were seemingly reverted as part of #243 but I don't see why?

[DirkToewe]

Sadly the hacky fix made in PR #231 does not work at all anymore with karma-jasmine 2.0.1