How to resolve INCOMPATIBLE_EXTENSIONS error

[mac3851]

✅ Prerequisites

• [ * ] Did you perform a cursory search of open issues? Is this question already asked elsewhere?
• [ * ] Are you reporting to the correct repository (magic-sdk)?

❓ Question

I'm using magic-sdk 4.4.2 and @magic-ext/oauth 0.9.0. When trying loginWithRedirect as described here, I',m receiving this error:

Uncaught Error: Magic SDK Error: [INCOMPATIBLE_EXTENSIONS] Some extensions are incompatible with `magic-sdk@4.4.2`:
  - Extension `oauth` supports version(s) `>=2.4.6`
    at new MagicSDKError (sdk-exceptions.js:17)
    at Object.exports.createIncompatibleExtensionsError (sdk-exceptions.js:138)
    at SDKBase.prepareExtensions (sdk.js:83)
    at new SDKBase (sdk.js:107)

I've tried to downgrade to magic-sdk 4.0.0 and oauth extension version to 0.7.0 (got the instructions from support), but id did not resolve the issue. I've also tried other versions.

🌎 Environment

Software	Version(s)
magic-sdk	4.4.2
Browser	Brave Version 1.26.74 Chromium: 91.0.4472.124 (Official Build) (64-bit)
yarn	v1.21.1
Operating System	Ubuntu 18.04.5 LTS

[smithki]

Can you provide a reproduction of the issue in CodeSandbox? I'm using this to quickly test the problem but cannot reproduce: https://codesandbox.io/s/condescending-star-nvnlm?file=/index.html

[mac3851]

Can you provide a reproduction of the issue in CodeSandbox? I'm using this to quickly test the problem but cannot reproduce: https://codesandbox.io/s/condescending-star-nvnlm?file=/index.html

I see you're using extensions: [new MagicOAuthExtension()] and the docs say: extensions: [new OAuthExtension()]. I'm using ClojureScript, I'll try to put it in sandbox.

[smithki]

I see you're using extensions: [new MagicOAuthExtension()] and the docs say: extensions: [new OAuthExtension()]. I'm using ClojureScript, I'll try to put it in sandbox.

Syntax differs slightly depending on whether you're consuming the SDK via CDN or NPM. When using our CDN, the extension class is prefixed with Magic* because it exists in the global namespace and we are aiming to prevent conflicts.

[smithki]

Took a deep dive into this issue and I believe it's related to an old cyclic dependency within the semver package. Apparently there's a known issue with bundling semver using Rollup that creates an unexpected behavior where semver.satisfies returns false always.

Related issues:

• commonjs: v19.0.0 breaks semver package rollup/plugins#879
• [BUG] Circular Dependency between comparator.js and range.js npm/node-semver#318
• [BUG] the package isn't compatible with Rollup due to require cycle npm/node-semver#381

We are in the midst of a refactor that will bundle all Magic SDK dependencies together before publishing to NPM. I have run into this bug myself while implementing that change. I will try to resolve it for you from our side and ping this issue when the fix goes out (should be in v6.0.0).

[smithki]

Please give this a try with magic-sdk@6.0.1 and let me know how it works for you. If the issue remains unresolved please feel free to ping this thread and I'll re-open the issue.