How to bind keys only for History Menu?

[JerryZhongJ]

I want to keep the default behaviors in zsh' history search, which is using ← and → to quit selection and move forward/backward a char in command, and pressing 'Enter' to run the command in the menu immediately. For now, when I find out a command from history menu, I need a double Enter to run it, which is quite inconvenient. If I want to modify the command, I need to press tab or Enter to quit the menu first, which I always forget, and this brings me a mess.

I tried the solution in README.md, but this does not only modify the key binding in History Menu, but also in Completion Menu.

bindkey -M menuselect '\r' .accept-line
bindkey -M menuselect "$terminfo[kcub1]" .backward-char
bindkey -M menuselect "$terminfo[kcuf1]" .forward-char      

But this is not what I want. When I press Enter in Completion Menu, what I mean is to select the item. And I can't move left and right among the items.

I know I can change the behavior of ↑ to the default of zsh, but I want to keep the History Menu because it is quite useful for me,

I think the solution is to change key binding only for History Menu. Can it be done?

[JerryZhongJ]

I figure out a solution, that is adding a wrapper to the two widgets, history-search and complete-word. The wrappers call bindkey every time the widgets are called.

I add this to my .zshrc:

wrap(){
  functions[${1}:old]="$(
      unfunction ${1} 2> /dev/null
      builtin autoload +X -Uz ~autocomplete/Functions/Widgets/${1}
      print -r -- "$functions[${1}]"
  )"
  eval "${1}(){
    bindkey -M menuselect $terminfo[kcub1] ${2}
    bindkey -M menuselect $terminfo[kcuf1] ${3}
    bindkey -M menuselect '\r' ${4}
    ${1}:old \$@
  }"
}
wrap .autocomplete__history-search__completion-widget .backward-char .forward-char .accept-line
wrap .autocomplete__complete-word__completion-widget backward-char forward-char accept-line
unfunction wrap

However this solution is too ugly, and will break if the function names are changed. I'm looking forward to a better solution.

[theerror]

Yes, this is exactly what case me trouble as well. I've come to zsh from bash and I do like this history, BUT exactly as you told the needs of confirming command before I'm able to edit it somehow is really pain and switching next / previous one, when I hit the left/right and my intended command disappears, it drives me creasy too. This definitely makes sense to map like this by default (end history / search and start moving cursor in command prompt).

[DreadPirateFlint]

My people! I figured I was the only person in the world so annoyed by such a very specific thing! Tried to explain it to my wife and she just looked at me like 'why did I marry this person'.