Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

strange behaviour #368

Open
yvesdecloedt opened this issue May 13, 2024 · 8 comments
Open

strange behaviour #368

yvesdecloedt opened this issue May 13, 2024 · 8 comments

Comments

@yvesdecloedt
Copy link

Hi,

I have set up the system and have paired 3 blinds
I use the smooth Somphy for my shutters
The blinds are metallic slates on wires which decend out of a box and they can tilt (as described in your document as integrated)

setup configurtation
Type : Blind
Up time 30000ms
Down time 30000ms
Tilt type Integrated
Tilt Time 1500ms

when using the virtual remote :

If I continuously pres up, shutter briefly moves up and stops
If I continuously press down, it goes down while I am pressing;

but sometimes it's the otherway around and sometime I have this behavior in both directions

If my tilt is completly closed, then the My button does nothing. I first need to press the UP and then the My works

On my remote if you press My it goes to the predefined position, if you press it again it stops. (using the software 'if' the My works then pressing it again does nothing)

I tried to play with the shutters in the Home tab (using target position an target tilt) but this has even more erratic behavior in my case

Probably misconfigured something, but not sure what else i can try ?

@rstrouse
Copy link
Owner

It sounds a lot like you have the motor configured for Euro-Tilt mode. However, there is really no command sequence that I have found in the protocol for continuous press of the buttons. It breaks this out into short press, medium press, and long press. The up and down buttons are simply a repeat until enough of them are received to call it a long press. ESPSomfy RTS has a Euro-Tilt setting.

Also, if you are using the same address as your remote for the ESPSomfy RTS configuration you will have strange issues where commands are first ignored (due to out of sequence rolling codes) and then can be activated. If this is the case then eventually neither the remote or ESPSomfy RTS will continue to function. At that point you will need to factory reset the motor and start over.

Some motors also have a pre-provisioned mode to allow you to set the endstops. However, these are typically done with a series of short presses.

As an aside the virtual remote tab was not designed to be the operational control for your blinds. It is there to emulate a remote so that if you do not actually have one you can get the provisioning accomplished. You need to verify whether you are using the Euro-Tilt setting on the motor, ensure you are not using the same address for ESPSomfy RTS as the remote, and time the movements for tilt and up/down. These will likely be different as gravity comes into play.

@yvesdecloedt
Copy link
Author

The address on the remote is 9911904 (in the log)
image
The adress on the ESP Somfu RTS is 649036
The Tilt is set to integrated:
image
timings have been set approximately correct 30 seonds down to up (or vice versa) and the Tilt takes 1,5 seconds to complete

If I press the button UP on my remote just once it does the same thing (small movement). If I continously push the button, say for 1-2 seconds, ths shutter moves for 1-2 seconds (in the log I see a series of up commands passing :
image
If I push for approx 3 seconds and release it goes up without stopping (or unless I Press My or down)
Output log.pdf

PS the target and tilt position does not do what it needs to do either. The animation shows it correctly but regardsless of the setting the shutter goes completely down (although it shows 0% )
image

@yvesdecloedt
Copy link
Author

I just had one finding and comment to avoid confusion;

when I mentioned virtual remote I meant the ESPSomphy RTS ((Home) as opposed to Smoove Somphy (physical remote)

What is strange is that the behavior on the ESPSomphy home is different then on the virtual remote tab.
The behavior is described is when pushing the button on the home tab.
When I push he up button on the virtual remote tab continously, then the shutter behaves as expected (moving for the duration of the push and after 3 seconds if continues)

@rstrouse
Copy link
Owner

That sounds like the motor is configured for Euro-Tilt. Either select that as your tilt type or even better look at the manual to turn that off. On the main home screen repeats are not processed while holding down the button. This is intentional to avoid long presses when not required.

@yvesdecloedt
Copy link
Author

The Euro-tilt does work somewhat better. (not sure what Euro-tilt stands for). On the ESPSomphy pressing once up, shiutter move up all the way. Pressing once down, moves down all the way. Settinh target position also seems to work. Target Tilt does not (only a very short movement)
The smoove remote and ESPSomph are out out of sync. After pressing remote down once, the shutter moves down a bit but the ESPSompy thinks the shutter is going down completely.
I added a video of the shutter:

video.mov

@rstrouse
Copy link
Owner

Honestly, I would change the mode on that motor. To get a target position for the tilt will be near impossible because of the long press processing and the short timing on the tilt duration it will never be accurate. The entire timing for long presses to start and stop the movement will be too close to the timing of the tilt.

@yvesdecloedt
Copy link
Author

ok I understand. Unfortunately these shutters are outside and I don't have access, nor any manual on how this could be done

@rstrouse
Copy link
Owner

Look online. Even if they are not Somfy branded they will likely follow the same power off then remote button combinations as Somfy to turn it on and off.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants