Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Incorrect inference of template definition using nested templates in function parameters #9094

Closed
emmanuelGuiton opened this issue Jan 11, 2023 · 1 comment · Fixed by #9095

Comments

@emmanuelGuiton
Copy link
Contributor

#8112, does not fix all type inference issues, in particular when nested templates are used to define function parameters, as illustrated in this case :
https://psalm.dev/r/0c33f892f1

@psalm-github-bot
Copy link

I found these snippets:

https://psalm.dev/r/0c33f892f1
<?php
/**
 * Interface for all DB entities that map to some data-model object.
 *
 * @template T
 */
interface DbEntity
{
    /**
     * Maps this entity to a data-model entity
     *
     * @return T Data-model entity to which this DB entity maps.
     */
    public function toCore();
}

/**
 * @template T of object
 */
abstract class EntityRepository {}

/**
 * Base entity repository with common tooling.
 *
 * @template T of object
 * @extends EntityRepository<T>
 */
abstract class DbEntityRepository
extends EntityRepository {}

interface ObjectId {}

/**
 * @template I of ObjectId
 */
interface AnObject {}

/**
 * Base entity repository with common tooling.
 *
 * @template I of ObjectId
 * @template O of AnObject<I>
 * @template E of DbEntity<O>
 * @extends DbEntityRepository<E>
 */
abstract class AnObjectEntityRepository
extends DbEntityRepository
{}

/**
 * Base repository implementation backed by a Db repository.
 *
 * @template T
 * @template E of DbEntity<T>
 * @template R of DbEntityRepository<E>
 */
abstract class DbRepositoryWrapper
{
    /** @var R $repo Db repository */
    private DbEntityRepository $repo;

    /**
     * Getter for the Db repository.
     *
     * @return DbEntityRepository The Db repository.
     * @psalm-return R
     */
    protected function getDbRepo(): DbEntityRepository
    {
        return $this->repo;
    }
}

/**
 * Base implementation for all custom repositories that map to Core objects.
 *
 * @template I of ObjectId
 * @template O of AnObject<I>
 * @template E of DbEntity<O>
 * @template R of AnObjectEntityRepository<I, O, E>
 * @extends DbRepositoryWrapper<O, E, R>
 */
abstract class AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper
extends DbRepositoryWrapper {}

abstract class Utilities {
    /**
     * @template I of ObjectId
     * @template O of AnObject<I>
     * @template E of DbEntity<O>
     * @template R of AnObjectEntityRepository<I, O, E>
     * @psalm-param AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper<I, O, E, R> $repo
     * @return void
     */
    abstract public static function doSomething(AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper $repo): void;
}
Psalm output (using commit 6bcd3bf):

ERROR: InvalidTemplateParam - 92:21 - Extended template param O of AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>, R:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObjectEntityRepository<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>>> expects type AnObject<I:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as ObjectId>, type O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId> given

ERROR: InvalidTemplateParam - 92:21 - Extended template param E of AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>, R:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObjectEntityRepository<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>>> expects type DbEntity<O:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as AnObject<I:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as ObjectId>>, type E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>> given

ERROR: InvalidTemplateParam - 92:21 - Extended template param R of AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>, R:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObjectEntityRepository<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>>> expects type AnObjectEntityRepository<I:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as ObjectId, O:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as AnObject<I:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as ObjectId>, E:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as DbEntity<O:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as AnObject<I:AnObjectDbRepositoryWrapper as ObjectId>>>, type R:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObjectEntityRepository<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>> given

ERROR: InvalidTemplateParam - 92:21 - Extended template param O of AnObjectEntityRepository<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>> expects type AnObject<I:AnObjectEntityRepository as ObjectId>, type O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId> given

ERROR: InvalidTemplateParam - 92:21 - Extended template param E of AnObjectEntityRepository<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId, O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>, E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>>> expects type DbEntity<O:AnObjectEntityRepository as AnObject<I:AnObjectEntityRepository as ObjectId>>, type E:fn-utilities::dosomething as DbEntity<O:fn-utilities::dosomething as AnObject<I:fn-utilities::dosomething as ObjectId>> given

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

1 participant