What is E2E Testing?

E2E testing is a software testing approach that simulates real-world user scenarios to ensure applications behave as expected and data flows seamlessly throughout various user tasks and processes. It essentially tests the application from the end user's perspective.

Example: Sign-up Form

Consider a sign-up form. Users might perform actions like:

• Entering a blank email and password
• Entering valid credentials
• Entering invalid credentials
• Clicking the sign-up button

E2E testing verifies these actions function as intended. An E2E testing framework would simulate a real user by automatically entering data and interacting with the sign-up button. The test would then check the application's responses:

• Does an error message appear for invalid data?
• Does successful registration occur with valid data?
• Do backend processes function correctly, like database updates and email notifications?

E2E Testing in a Comprehensive Strategy

While E2E testing sounds thorough, it's just one piece of a robust testing strategy. Here are other testing methods to combine with E2E testing for enhanced software quality and reliability:

• Unit testing: Ensures individual software components function as expected.
• Integration testing: Combines and tests individual software modules as a group.
• Security testing: Evaluates the software for vulnerabilities and ensures data protection from external threats.
• Accessibility testing: Ensures the software is usable for people with disabilities, adhering to accessibility standards.
• Usability testing: Evaluates how user-friendly the application is, focusing on how easily users can complete tasks.

Importance of End-to-end Testing

End-to-end (E2E) testing stands out as an essential practice for delivering high-quality software that functions flawlessly for users. It achieves this by simulating real-world user scenarios, providing a comprehensive assessment of an application's functionality. Here's a deeper dive into the advantages E2E testing offers:

• Enhanced Test Coverage: E2E testing goes beyond the granular focus of unit testing and the component-level checks of integration testing. It encompasses the entire user journey, incorporating a wider range of test cases that delve into how various application parts interact with each other and with external systems. This holistic approach helps uncover issues that might slip through the cracks with more isolated testing methods.

• Realistic User Experience: E2E testing prioritizes user behavior. By mimicking real user interactions, it exposes areas where the application might malfunction or fall short of user expectations. This user-centric perspective ensures that the software functions as intended in practical use cases, leading to a more intuitive and user-friendly experience.

• Streamlined Release Cycles: Automation is a key aspect of E2E testing. By automating critical user paths, E2E testing can expedite the release process. Tests can be triggered automatically whenever code changes are introduced, providing faster feedback and reducing the time it takes to identify and fix bugs. This efficiency translates to quicker releases and shorter time-to-market windows.

• Cost-Effective Development: Early detection of bugs is paramount for cost-effective software development. E2E testing excels in this area by uncovering issues before they become deeply embedded in the codebase. This proactive approach saves development teams significant time and resources that would otherwise be spent fixing bugs later in the development lifecycle.

• Improved User Satisfaction: Ultimately, E2E testing benefits the end user by ensuring a smooth and reliable application experience. By mimicking real user interactions, E2E testing helps identify and resolve issues before they impact users. This leads to software that is not only functional but also intuitive and user-friendly, fostering higher user satisfaction.

The advantages of E2E testing extend beyond core functionality, positively impacting various stakeholders involved in the software development process:

• Developers and QA Teams: In organizations with separate QA teams, E2E testing can free up developer bandwidth. Since E2E tests are based on user behavior, often documented from usability testing, they can be easier for testers to create. Additionally, E2E testing integrates seamlessly with automated workflows in a DevOps environment. Tests can be triggered automatically with code commits, providing developers with immediate feedback on any regressions introduced by their changes.

• Managers: E2E testing offers valuable insights into how different parts of the application work together in a real-world context. This visibility empowers managers to strategically prioritize tasks that directly impact user experience and system stability. By pinpointing areas that need the most attention, E2E testing helps optimize resource allocation and development efforts, ultimately leading to a higher quality product.

In conclusion, E2E testing plays a critical role in modern software development. By incorporating a user-centric approach, comprehensive test coverage, and automation capabilities, E2E testing delivers a multitude of benefits for developers, testers, managers, and most importantly, the end users. This comprehensive testing strategy ensures the delivery of high-quality software that meets user expectations and fosters long-term user satisfaction.

Expanded E2E Testing Example: Online Shopping

This scenario simulates a customer purchasing a product on an e-commerce website, encompassing various functionalities and integrations. The goal is to verify a seamless and successful buying experience.

Test Steps:

1. Product Search and Selection:

   • User searches for a specific product using the search bar or browses through categories.
   • Verify search results are relevant and product listings display accurate information (name, description, price, availability, images).
   • User selects the desired product size, color, or other variations (if applicable).
   • Verify stock levels are updated dynamically as products are added to the cart.

2. Shopping Cart and Checkout:

   • User adds the chosen product(s) to the shopping cart.
   • Verify the shopping cart accurately reflects chosen items, quantities, and prices.
   • User proceeds to checkout and logs in with a valid account or creates a new account.
   • Verify the checkout process is secure and requires necessary user information (billing address, shipping address, contact details).
   • User selects a preferred shipping method and verifies associated costs and estimated delivery times are displayed.

3. Payment Processing:

   • User enters valid payment information (credit card number, expiration date, CVV code) or selects an alternative payment method (if offered).
   • Verify the payment gateway securely handles sensitive information and adheres to industry security standards (e.g., PCI compliance).
   • User confirms the order with the final total amount displayed clearly.

4. Order Confirmation and Communication:

   • Verify the website displays a confirmation message upon successful payment, including order details (order number, purchase summary, estimated delivery date).
   • Check the customer's email inbox for an order confirmation email containing the following information:
     • Order number
     • Customer information (billing and shipping details)
     • Itemized list of purchased products (name, quantity, price)
     • Order total amount
     • Shipping information (shipping method, estimated delivery date)
     • Company contact details and return policy information

5. Account Verification:

   • User logs in to their account on the website.
   • Verify the purchase is reflected in the order history section, displaying details consistent with the confirmation email.
   • User can access the order details and track the shipment status (if available).

Additional Considerations:

• Test with different product types, variations, and quantities to ensure the system handles various scenarios.
• Include negative test cases (e.g., invalid login credentials, incorrect payment information, insufficient stock) to verify the system provides appropriate error messages and prevents invalid actions.
• Perform the tests on different browsers and devices (desktop, mobile, tablet) to ensure consistent user experience across platforms.

Benefits

End-to-End (E2E) testing has become an indispensable practice in modern software development. Its significance transcends mere functionality verification, offering a spectrum of benefits that elevate software quality and guarantee a stellar user experience. Let's delve deeper and explore how E2E testing empowers the creation of exceptional software:

• Holistic Quality Assurance Across Layers: Modern applications are intricate ecosystems comprised of numerous layers working in unison. While individual components might function flawlessly in isolation, unforeseen issues can arise when they interact. E2E testing bridges this gap by meticulously simulating real-world user journeys. It validates how these layers seamlessly interconnect, ensuring smooth data flow and preventing potential conflicts that might remain undetected during isolated testing of individual layers.

• Solidifying the Foundation: Prioritizing Backend Functionality: A robust foundation is essential for any structure. E2E testing prioritizes backend verification, placing particular emphasis on the application's database – the lifeblood that feeds data to all other layers. By meticulously scrutinizing database interactions, E2E testing safeguards data integrity and proactively prevents downstream issues that could cripple the application's functionality.

• Ensuring Consistent User Experience Across Diverse Environments: A seamless user experience is the cornerstone of success in today's competitive landscape. E2E testing extends beyond basic functionality verification by meticulously assessing how the application performs across a broad spectrum of environments. This encompasses testing on various browsers, devices (desktops, mobiles, tablets), and platforms through techniques like cross-browser testing. This rigorous approach ensures users encounter a consistent and exceptional experience regardless of their chosen platform.

• Bridging the Gap with Third-Party Systems: Many applications integrate external systems to handle specific tasks. E2E testing plays a critical role here by verifying seamless compatibility between internal and external systems. It meticulously examines how these systems exchange data, preventing disruptions that could hinder core functionalities and compromise user experience.

Streamlined End-to-End Testing Life Cycle

E2E testing adheres to a well-defined life cycle with distinct phases:

1. Test Planning: Following the completion of integration testing, a meticulous test plan is crafted. This plan outlines the testing objectives meticulously aligned with initial client requirements and the application's architecture. It serves as a comprehensive roadmap for the entire E2E testing process.

2. Test Design: A dedicated test environment is established to closely replicate real-world conditions, often leveraging existing configurations from previous testing phases. Risk and usage analyses are conducted to optimize resource allocation and ensure test cases effectively target potential issues. Automation tools are frequently employed during this phase to streamline test design and minimize manual effort.

3. Test Execution: Test cases are meticulously executed, often encompassing both local and remote environments. During this phase, progress is closely monitored to ensure strict adherence to the initial test plan.

4. Results Analysis: The culmination of the testing life cycle involves a thorough analysis of test results. This analysis meticulously identifies the root cause of any bugs or defects encountered. These findings are then promptly communicated to the development team for swift rectification. Finally, a project retrospective is conducted to evaluate the testing process, identify areas for improvement, and refine future E2E testing efforts.

Types of End-to-End Testing

End-to-end (E2E) testing plays a pivotal role in ensuring software applications function flawlessly from a user's perspective. But within the E2E testing realm, two primary approaches exist: horizontal and vertical testing. Understanding these distinctions empowers you to create a more targeted and effective testing strategy.

Horizontal E2E Testing: The User in the Driver's Seat

Imagine yourself as a typical user interacting with an application. Horizontal E2E testing mirrors this experience. Testers prioritize workflows that users encounter most frequently, meticulously examining each step of the journey.

Here's a breakdown of horizontal E2E testing in action:

• E-commerce Example: Consider an e-commerce website. A horizontal E2E test might involve:
  • Searching for a specific product using the search bar.
  • Verifying product listings display accurate details (name, description, price, availability, images).
  • Adding the desired product to the shopping cart and checking if the cart reflects chosen items, quantities, and prices accurately.
  • Proceeding through checkout, logging in with valid credentials, or creating a new account.
  • Selecting a preferred shipping method and verifying associated costs and estimated delivery times.
  • Entering valid payment information and confirming the order with the final total amount displayed clearly.
  • Upon successful payment, verifying the website displays a confirmation message with order details.
  • Checking the customer's email inbox for an order confirmation email containing relevant information.
  • Logging in to the customer's account on the website and verifying the purchase is reflected in the order history section.

In essence, horizontal E2E testing focuses on user-centric experiences, ensuring a smooth and error-free journey from start to finish.

Vertical E2E Testing: Delving Deeper into the Backstage

Vertical E2E testing adopts a more technical perspective. Testers shift their focus from the user interface to the intricate inner workings of the application. The objective is to verify seamless data flow and ensure backend processes function as intended.

Let's revisit the e-commerce example with a vertical E2E testing lens:

• Verifying Data Integrity: Testing data flow throughout the application is paramount. This might involve ensuring accurate product information is retrieved from the database and displayed on product pages.
• Backend Processes: Validating core functionalities like secure user account creation, efficient order processing, and successful payment transaction completion are crucial aspects of vertical E2E testing.
• API Interactions: Modern applications often leverage APIs to interact with external systems. Vertical E2E testing might involve verifying data exchange between the application and these external APIs.

Choosing the Right Approach: A Strategic Blend

While horizontal and vertical E2E testing have distinct focuses, they are not mutually exclusive. A well-rounded testing strategy often incorporates elements of both approaches.

• Horizontal E2E testing provides invaluable insights into the user experience and identifies user-facing issues.
• Vertical E2E testing guarantees the underlying technical infrastructure is robust and supports a seamless user experience.

Common tools used in E2E testing

End-to-end (E2E) testing tools are instrumental for streamlining the automation of comprehensive test cases. Here's a closer look at some popular options, along with considerations for choosing the best fit for your needs:

Web Application Testing

• Selenium: The granddaddy of web browser automation, Selenium offers extensive language and framework support, making it a versatile choice. However, its configuration can be complex, requiring more development expertise.

• Cypress: Known for its speed and user-friendliness, Cypress executes tests directly in the browser. This simplifies setup and debugging, but it might not be ideal for highly complex testing scenarios.

• TestCafe: This Node.js-based tool boasts strong browser compatibility and provides clear reporting features. While it offers a robust solution, the learning curve can be steeper compared to some options.

• Puppeteer: Developed by Google, Puppeteer leverages Chrome's DevTools protocol for testing. It excels in headless Chrome or Chromium testing but might require familiarity with Google's ecosystem.

• Playwright: A younger contender from Microsoft, Playwright extends Puppeteer's functionality to Firefox and WebKit. While promising for cross-browser testing, it's still under active development.

Mobile App Testing

• Appium: This popular tool facilitates E2E testing on both iOS and Android devices from a single API. It offers broad platform coverage but can have a steeper learning curve compared to some web-focused options.

All-in-one Solutions

• Katalon Studio: This comprehensive platform caters to web, API, mobile, and desktop application testing. It provides a user-friendly interface but might lack the deep customization capabilities of some individual tools.

General Recommendations:

For beginners, Cypress or a user-friendly all-in-one solution like Katalon Studio can be a good starting point. If you prioritize cross-browser testing and have experience with JavaScript, Playwright might be an excellent choice. For complex web application testing scenarios, Selenium offers ultimate flexibility but demands a steeper learning curve. Mobile app testing often leans towards Appium due to its comprehensive platform support.

Challenges of end-to-end testing

The Enigmatic E2E: Unveiling Challenges and Strategies

End-to-end (E2E) testing stands as a powerful tool for ensuring software quality, mimicking real-world user journeys and encompassing a broad range of functionalities. However, this comprehensive approach comes with its own set of challenges that require careful consideration.

Time Constraints: The Balancing Act

One of the most significant hurdles in E2E testing is the time investment it demands. Crafting effective test cases necessitates a thorough understanding of the product's intricacies. This in-depth knowledge translates to longer setup times compared to other testing methods. Additionally, E2E tests can be computationally expensive to execute. Simulating real user interactions across various components and systems introduces complexity, potentially leading to slower test runtimes.

Strategic Deployment: Prioritizing Efficiency

To mitigate the time constraints, development teams often employ a strategic deployment approach. Unit tests and integration tests are typically integrated throughout the development lifecycle, providing continuous feedback. E2E testing, with its resource-intensive nature, is then reserved for the most critical user workflows. These tests are predominantly run in staging environments before final deployment, minimizing disruptions during development while upholding production quality standards.

The Intricacy of Test Design: A Multi-faceted Endeavor

Designing effective E2E tests requires meticulous consideration of numerous factors. Unlike unit or integration tests that focus on isolated components, E2E testing replicates real-world user behavior. This necessitates accounting for various interacting elements, such as:

• Browser Compatibility: Web applications may run differently on various browsers, each with its own set of specifications. This can lead to the creation of browser-specific test cases, significantly increasing development effort and potentially causing budget overruns.

• Test-Driven Development (TDD): E2E tests, with their inherent slow execution times, are not ideal for TDD, a methodology that emphasizes rapid feedback on code changes. Alternative testing methods might be better suited for this purpose.

Understanding User Intent: Beyond the Features

Effective E2E testing goes beyond merely verifying if features function as intended. It delves deeper, assessing how well the application addresses users' core problems and facilitates their desired outcomes.

However, not all development teams possess a comprehensive understanding of user goals. This necessitates the implementation of user research techniques early in the development process. Gathering user perspectives and requirements is crucial for crafting E2E tests that align with real-world needs. While user research can be a valuable investment, it can also be costly. As a result, teams might resort to relying on a limited pool of users, often referred to as "beta testers." This approach, while cost-effective, might not capture the full spectrum of user behaviors and needs.

The Final Verdict: A Measured Approach

Despite the challenges, E2E testing remains an invaluable asset. It offers the most comprehensive assessment of how software functions in real-world scenarios. In today's competitive software landscape, the ability to not only meet technical specifications but also deliver a seamless user experience is paramount. E2E testing, when implemented strategically and with an awareness of its limitations, empowers developers to create high-quality software that thrives in the marketplace. By acknowledging the time constraints, intricacies of test design, and importance of understanding user goals, teams can navigate the challenges associated with E2E testing and unlock its full potential.

implement end-to-end testing

End-to-End (E2E) testing offers a comprehensive approach to software quality assurance, mimicking real-world user journeys and encompassing a broad range of functionalities. Here's a detailed breakdown of the steps involved in implementing E2E testing:

1. Planning and Preparation:

• Review Requirements: Begin by meticulously reviewing the application's requirements. This forms the foundation for crafting effective E2E test cases that validate the software's functionality against its intended purpose.

• Test Environment Setup: Establish a dedicated test environment that closely mirrors the production environment. This ensures the tests are executed under conditions that resemble real-world usage scenarios.

• System and Subsystems Analysis: Define all the processes and interactions within the system and its constituent subsystems. This comprehensive understanding is crucial for designing tests that cover various functionalities and potential integration points.

• Roles and Responsibilities: Outline the roles and responsibilities of each system and subsystem. This clarity aids in pinpointing potential areas of concern during testing and assigning ownership for identified issues.

• Testing Tools and Frameworks: Select appropriate testing tools and frameworks that align with your project's requirements and your team's expertise. Popular options include Selenium, Cypress, Appium, and Katalon Studio.

• Test Case Design Requirements: List the specific requirements that need to be considered when designing E2E test cases. This might include user access levels, data variations, and expected system responses under different conditions.

• Input and Output Data: Identify the input and output data for each system involved in the E2E testing process. This ensures proper data flow and helps validate system behavior based on various inputs.

2. Manual Testing: A Stepping Stone

• Identify Test Cases: Before diving into automation, consider manual testing as an initial step. Manual exploration allows testers to identify potential test cases and uncover hidden user interaction paths within the application. This hands-on approach provides valuable insights for subsequent automation efforts.

• Horizontal vs. Vertical Testing: Manual testing can be conducted using two primary approaches:

  • Horizontal E2E Testing: This approach covers the entire user journey, encompassing workflows that span multiple subsystems. An example might be a test simulating a user registering, searching for a product, adding it to the cart, checking out, and receiving an order confirmation email.

  • Vertical E2E Testing: This approach breaks down the application into individual layers (e.g., UI, database, backend logic) and tests them sequentially. This method allows for focused troubleshooting within each layer before integrating them for horizontal testing.

3. Automation for Efficiency:

• Scaling Up with Automation: As your project grows in complexity, manual testing becomes increasingly time-consuming and prone to human error. Automation is essential for managing a large suite of E2E tests efficiently and consistently.

• Selecting Test Cases: Choose the most critical and frequently used user workflows for automation. This prioritization ensures that core functionalities are thoroughly tested while optimizing automation efforts.

• Writing Automated Tests: Develop the automated test scripts using your chosen testing framework. These scripts will simulate user interactions and verify system behavior against predefined expectations.

• Integration with CI/CD: Integrate your automated E2E tests with your continuous integration and continuous delivery (CI/CD) pipeline. This enables automatic test execution with every code change, fostering a culture of rapid feedback and early defect detection.

Remember: E2E testing is an iterative process. As you gather results, you may need to refine your test cases, adjust automation scripts, and continuously improve your testing strategy to ensure comprehensive coverage and a high-quality software product.

Following the comprehensive guide outlined previously, let's delve into a practical example of implementing E2E testing for a common scenario: online shopping on an e-commerce website.

1. Planning and Preparation:

• Review Requirements: Analyze the e-commerce platform's requirements. This includes functionalities like product search, browsing, adding items to cart, user account management, checkout process, and payment processing.

• Test Environment Setup: Establish a dedicated test environment that replicates the live website as closely as possible. This ensures the tests accurately reflect real-world user experiences.

• System and Subsystems Analysis: Identify the key components of the e-commerce platform: product catalog, shopping cart, user accounts, payment gateway, and order processing system. Understand how these components interact with each other.

• Roles and Responsibilities: Define the roles of each system and subsystem. This might include the product database, shopping cart functionality, user authentication, and payment processing.

• Testing Tools and Frameworks: Choose a suitable testing framework like Selenium or Cypress. These tools allow you to automate user interactions and verify system behavior.

• Test Case Design Requirements: List the specific requirements for E2E test cases. This might include user roles (registered vs. guest), product variations (in stock, out of stock), and different payment methods.

• Input and Output Data: Identify the data used throughout the testing process. This includes product details, user credentials, shipping information, and payment data. Ensure proper data flow between systems.

2. Manual Testing: A Stepping Stone

• Identify Test Cases: Perform exploratory manual testing to discover user journeys and potential test cases. This might involve searching for specific products, adding them to the cart with varying quantities, and navigating the checkout process with different user accounts and payment methods.

3. Automation for Efficiency:

• Selecting Test Cases: Prioritize critical user journeys for automation. Focus on core functionalities like:

  • User Registration and Login
  • Product Search and Browsing
  • Adding Items to Cart and Updating Quantities
  • Secure Checkout Process with Valid and Invalid Payment Information
  • Order Confirmation and Email Receipt

• Writing Automated Tests: Develop automated test scripts using your chosen framework. These scripts will simulate user interactions such as entering search terms, adding products to the cart, filling out checkout forms, and submitting payment information.

• Verifying System Behavior: The automated tests will verify various aspects throughout the user journey:

  • Successful product search results based on search criteria
  • Accurate product information displayed on product pages
  • Ability to add and remove items from the shopping cart
  • Correct calculation of total order amount based on product prices and quantities
  • Acceptance of valid payment information during checkout
  • Order confirmation with order details displayed upon successful purchase
  • Delivery of an order confirmation email containing relevant information

• Integration with CI/CD: Integrate your automated E2E tests into your CI/CD pipeline. This allows for automatic test execution with every code change, ensuring early detection of regressions and maintaining a high level of software quality.

End-to-End Testing Best Practices

Here are the key takeaways for best practices in End-to-End (E2E) testing:

• Prioritize Critical Workflows: Focus on the most frequently used and essential functionalities of your application. Break down these workflows into smaller steps for targeted testing. This ensures your E2E tests cover the user journeys that matter most.

• Avoid Exception Testing for E2E: While exception testing is valuable, it's not the primary focus of E2E testing. E2E testing aims to validate user workflows under normal conditions, not necessarily how the system behaves during errors.

• Minimize UI Flakiness: E2E tests often involve user interface (UI) interactions, which can be susceptible to flakiness due to external factors like network issues or slow servers. To address this, consider using features like Katalon Studio's Smart Wait to ensure elements are fully loaded before proceeding with test actions.

• Embrace Automation: E2E testing involves complex interactions across various system components. Leverage automation testing tools to streamline the process and ensure efficiency.

• Utilize a Software Quality Management Platform: For managing E2E testing effectively, consider using a software quality management platform. This platform offers a centralized hub for organizing test cases, requirements, plans, and defects, fostering better collaboration and streamlined testing efforts.

Example :

• Typescript(src directory)
• JavaScript(src directory)
• Golong