Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
doc: add guide about abi stability
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
  • Loading branch information
Gabriel Schulhof committed Oct 2, 2018
1 parent 97f1e94 commit f9e2295
Showing 1 changed file with 107 additions and 0 deletions.
107 changes: 107 additions & 0 deletions doc/guides/abi-stability.md
@@ -0,0 +1,107 @@
# ABI Stability

## Introduction
An Application Binary Interface (ABI) is the compiled version of an Application
Programming Interface (API). That is, the headers files describing the classes,
functions, data structures, enumerations, and constants used to enable an
application to perform a desired task correspond by way of compilation to a set
of addresses and expected parameter values and memory structure sizes and
layouts with which the provider of the ABI was compiled.

The application using the ABI must be compiled such that the available
addresses, expected parameter values, and memory structure sizes and layouts
agree with those with which the ABI provider was compiled. This is usually
accomplished by compiling against the headers provided by the ABI provider.

Since the ABI provider and the ABI user may be compiled at different times with
different versions of the compiler, a portion of the responsibility for
ensuring ABI compatibility lies with the compiler. Different versions of the
compiler, perhaps provided by different vendors, must all produce the same ABI
from a header file with a certain content, and must produce code for the
application using the ABI that accesses the API described in a given header
according to the conventions of the ABI resulting from the description in the
header. Modern compilers have a fairly good track record of not breaking the
ABI compatibility of the applications they compile.

The remaining responsibility for ensuring ABI compatibility lies with the team
maintaining the header files which provide the API that results, upon
compilation, in the ABI that is to remain stable. Changes to the header files
can be made, but the nature of the changes has to be closely tracked to ensure
that, upon compilation, the ABI does not change in a way that will render
existing users of the ABI incompatible with the new version.

## ABI Stability in Node.js
Node.js provides header files maintained by several independent teams. For
example, header files such as `node.h` and `node_buffer.h` are maintained by
the Node.js team. `v8.h` is maintained by the V8 team, which, although in close
co-operation with the Node.js team, is independent, and with its own schedule
and priorities. Thus, the Node.js team has only partial control over the
changes that are introduced in the headers the project provides. As a result,
the Node.js project has adopted [semantic versioning](https://semver.org/).
This ensures that the APIs provided by the project will result in a stable ABI
for all minor and patch versions of Node.js released within one major version.
In practice, this means that a Node.js native addon compiled against a given
major version of Node.js will load successfully when loaded by any Node.js
minor or patch version within the major version against which it was compiled.

## N-API
Demand has arisen for equipping Node.js with an API that results in an ABI that
remains stable across multiple Node.js versions. The motivation for creating
such an API is as follows:
* The JavaScript language has remained compatible with itself since its very
early days, whereas the ABI of the engine executing the JavaScript changes with
every major version of Node.js. This means that applications consisting of
Node.js packages written entirely in JavaScript need not be recompiled,
reinstalled, or redeployed as a new major version of Node.js is dropped into
the production environment in which such applications run. In contrast, if an
application depends on a package that contains a native addon, the application
has to be recompiled, reinstalled, and redeployed whenever a new major version
of Node.js is introduced into the production environment. This disparity
between Node.js packages containing native addons and those that are written
entirely in JavaScript has added to the maintenance burden of production
systems which rely on native addons.

* Other projects have started to produce JavaScript interfaces that are
essentially alternative implementations of Node.js. Since these projects are
usually built on a different JavaScript engine than V8, their native addons
necessarily take on a different structure and use a different API. Nevertheless,
using a single API for a native addon across different implementations of the
Node.js JavaScript API would allow these projects to take advantage of the
ecosystem of JavaScript packages that has accrued around Node.js.

* Node.js may contain a different JavaScript engine in the future. This means
that, externally, all Node.js interfaces would remain the same, but the V8
header file would be absent. Such a step would cause the disruption of the
Node.js ecosystem in general, and that of the native addons in particular, if
an API that is JavaScript engine agnostic is not first provided by Node.js and
adopted by native addons.

To these ends Node.js has introduced N-API in version 8.6.0 and marked it as a
stable component of the project as of Node.js 8.12.0. The API is defined in the
headers [`node_api.h`](https://github.com/nodejs/node/blob/master/src/node_api.h)
and [`node_api_types.h`](https://github.com/nodejs/node/blob/master/src/node_api_types.h),
and provides a forward-compatibility guarantee that crosses the Node.js major
version boundary. The guarantee can be stated as follows:

**A given version *n* of N-API will be available in the major version of
Node.js in which it was published, and in all subsequent versions of Node.js,
including subsequent major versions.**

A native addon author can take advantage of the N-API forward compatibility
guarantee by ensuring that the addon makes use only of APIs defined in
`node_api.h` and data structures and constants defined in `node_api_types.h`.
By doing so, the author facilitates adoption of their addon by indicating to
production users that the maintenance burden for their application will increase
no more by the addition of the native addon to their project than it would by
the addition of a package written purely in JavaScript.

N-API is versioned because new APIs are added from time to time. Unlike
semantic versioning, N-API versioning is cumulative. That is, each version of
N-API conveys the same meaning as a minor version in the semver system.
Additionally, new N-APIs are added under an experimental flag. This means that,
although care has been taken to ensure that the new API will not have to be
modified in an ABI-incompatible way in the future, it has not yet been proven in
production to be correct and useful as designed and, as such, may undergo
ABI-incompatible changes before it is finally incorporated into a forthcoming
version of N-API. That is, an experimental N-API is not covered by the forward
compatibility guarantee.

0 comments on commit f9e2295

Please sign in to comment.