Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add Hagezi Threat Intelligence Feeds #119

Closed
wants to merge 1 commit into from

Conversation

yokoffing
Copy link

@yokoffing yokoffing commented Sep 6, 2023

Hey @romaincointepas,

Thank you for merging a previously popular pull request: #65. By extension, many of us would also like to also have Hagezi's Threat Intelligence Feeds (TIF) to compliment our other blocklists.

Please offer @hagezi's TIF blocklist as an option. Details: https://github.com/hagezi/dns-blocklists#tif

Thanks for your support,

yokoffing
Maintainer of NextDNS Config guide

@RaggyShaggy
Copy link

Would love to see it.

@fynks
Copy link

fynks commented Sep 6, 2023

It would be best

@subhajitsaha97
Copy link

Please consider adding the list.

@jimmymcdermott
Copy link

Please add!

@hagezi
Copy link
Contributor

hagezi commented Sep 6, 2023

Good luck ;)

@mvnixon
Copy link

mvnixon commented Sep 6, 2023

please add

@dartsmaster
Copy link

This would be an excellent addition to the blocklists.

@BoDoPs
Copy link

BoDoPs commented Sep 6, 2023

Yes, this would be a great add.

@ericafterdark
Copy link

Has my vote!

@Spark4000
Copy link

C`mon NextDNS, make it happen

@FookunKlez
Copy link

Yes please

@hmbarbosa
Copy link

Awesome job!!!

@miltonjsvidal
Copy link

Thanks for this!!

@thiendt2k1
Copy link

Dont even know if they are keeping tab on this whole filter lists topic, i request 3 or 4 different blocklists but none got respond. Shame on NextDNS!

@live4swell
Copy link

👍🏻

@NanashiTheNameless
Copy link

I would absolutely love this

@gautaus
Copy link

gautaus commented Sep 7, 2023

👍

@adamk1211
Copy link

Yes please.

@wengkitttt
Copy link

Please add this blocklist !

@jimvajda
Copy link

Pretty please?

@Sandbox8888
Copy link

Please add.

@BourbonCrow
Copy link

Please add this

@0xvino
Copy link

0xvino commented Sep 24, 2023

Nextdns pls add this (I'm a paid nextdns user)

@DragonWolf5589
Copy link

This is one of the top features I would like implementing to next dns.

Even if they can't add this exact list allow us a way to import custom ones so we can do it ourselves!

@LunaticBFF57
Copy link

Been like 6 weeks and no response from dev team?

@hagezi
Copy link
Contributor

hagezi commented Oct 18, 2023

Available in AdGuardDNS, ControlD, RethinkDNS and DNSwarden.

@live4swell
Copy link

Any idea what NextDNS uses as their source for threat intelligence feeds?

@LunaticBFF57
Copy link

LunaticBFF57 commented Oct 19, 2023

Any idea what NextDNS uses as their source for threat intelligence feeds?

@live4swell, they use "a blend of the most reputable threat intelligence feeds". (Direct quote from website.) It will most likely continue being a secret because of 'trade secrets'.

@serqrevp
Copy link

serqrevp commented Nov 3, 2023

Please add the TIF list.

@wengkitttt
Copy link

Hey @romaincointepas,

Hope you're doing well! It's been 12 weeks since @yokoffing opened this pull request. Any chance to get it merged? We're all pretty excited about the Hagezi Threat Intelligence Feeds being part of NextDNS.

If there's any hiccup or reason you can't merge it, please let us know. We'd really appreciate it!

Thanks you.

@BourbonCrow
Copy link

Hey @romaincointepas,

Hope you're doing well! It's been 12 weeks since @yokoffing opened this pull request. Any chance to get it merged? We're all pretty excited about the Hagezi Threat Intelligence Feeds being part of NextDNS.

If there's any hiccup or reason you can't merge it, please let us know. We'd really appreciate it!

Thanks you.

It has been months since any updates on any of their repositorys. Without any word, I mean sure they have never been good at communicating but posting like 4 words or something on X or whatever social media they prefer letting ppl know what's going on sometimes would be nice. Not asking for a essay, only sign of life at this point haha

@LunaticBFF57
Copy link

LunaticBFF57 commented Dec 3, 2023

Hey @romaincointepas,
Hope you're doing well! It's been 12 weeks since @yokoffing opened this pull request. Any chance to get it merged? We're all pretty excited about the Hagezi Threat Intelligence Feeds being part of NextDNS.
If there's any hiccup or reason you can't merge it, please let us know. We'd really appreciate it!
Thanks you.

It has been months since any updates on any of their repositorys. Without any word, I mean sure they have never been good at communicating but posting like 4 words or something on X or whatever social media they prefer letting ppl know what's going on sometimes would be nice. Not asking for a essay, only sign of life at this point haha

@BourbonCrow, @romaincointepas may be working on DNS0.EU.

PS. They are the founder of that company.

@BourbonCrow
Copy link

Hey @romaincointepas,
Hope you're doing well! It's been 12 weeks since @yokoffing opened this pull request. Any chance to get it merged? We're all pretty excited about the Hagezi Threat Intelligence Feeds being part of NextDNS.
If there's any hiccup or reason you can't merge it, please let us know. We'd really appreciate it!
Thanks you.

It has been months since any updates on any of their repositorys. Without any word, I mean sure they have never been good at communicating but posting like 4 words or something on X or whatever social media they prefer letting ppl know what's going on sometimes would be nice. Not asking for a essay, only sign of life at this point haha

@BourbonCrow, @romaincointepas may be working on DNS0.EU.

PS. They are the founder of that company.

You are probably correct about them working on that since it's somewhat new. But a word from em would be nice. Concider NextDNS is a payed service and they prioritize a free service that I'm confused why it even exist. Like whatever dns0 is atm they could have made the free tier of NextDNS I'm confused why it needed a new company and branding doing the same thing even using same software as it states on dns0 site.. That it has been tested with next dns for years

@LudnicaKiller
Copy link

Would love to see it 😊

@wengkitttt
Copy link

Still no response from the dev 💀

@LunaticBFF57
Copy link

Are there any other devs that can commit to this repo?

@ittairuf
Copy link

ittairuf commented Feb 1, 2024

@romaincointepas and @rs please give us an update.

@DragonWolf5589
Copy link

DragonWolf5589 commented Feb 2, 2024

Its no wonder people are moving away/saying nextdns is "abandoned" im thinking if switching to a competitor one of these days and rsetting everything up again if they dont add this or at LEAST show they are active/still supporting nextdns.

(edit: spelling mistake)

@BourbonCrow
Copy link

Its no wonder people are moving away/saying nextdns is "abandoned" im thinking if switching to a competitor one of these days and rsetting everything up again if they dont add this or at LEAST show they are active/still supporting nextdns.

(edit: spelling mistake)

I'm annoyed with them being 100% just vanished and dont deal with old issues like removing old out dated filters and removing the outdated filters from their main filter and their list where you add your own domains whitelist and blocklist could be a bit better so you could add multiple domains.. and even like control D to organize in folders would be great with a import export. so I'm currently trying out ControlD a bit while i montitor the situation over at nextdns
pros:

  • UI is nice and easy to work with
  • easy to add / import your own lil list of domains or TLD's no need to input them 1 by 1,
  • they do have all the hagezi stuff including the TIF

cons:

  • i would say their own filters seems a bit of a mess atm way to many false positives on their crypty/malware (they seem pretty fast at fixing the reports on discord)

@wengkitttt
Copy link

@BourbonCrow I tried ControlD too, it took some time to get used to their UI. The dev team listens to their customers, and any issues are solved quickly. But, too bad I can't make the switch because I'm living in Asia, and the servers in Asia are quite bad when compared with NextDNS. I hope ControlD can increase and improve their servers in the Asia region.

By the way, if you guys go check out NextDNS other repository, there is still ongoing development, which means they can actually look into the issues in this repository, but they choose to ignore it? I'm not sure.

I wish the NextDNS dev team can have some response to this PR.

@BourbonCrow
Copy link

@BourbonCrow I tried ControlD too, it took some time to get used to their UI. The dev team listens to their customers, and any issues are solved quickly. But, too bad I can't make the switch because I'm living in Asia, and the servers in Asia are quite bad when compared with NextDNS. I hope ControlD can increase and improve their servers in the Asia region.

By the way, if you guys go check out NextDNS other repository, there is still ongoing development, which means they can actually look into the issues in this repository, but they choose to ignore it? I'm not sure.

I wish the NextDNS dev team can have some response to this PR.

@wengkitttt sweden ping on controld is like 30~ and nextdns is like..13 cause nextdns got servers in sweden but in for me non of the latencys are noticable cause both are very long, but i hope for you that they add a asian server.

also even if they dont wanna write massive blob posts.. i think next dns ppl could atleast spend... 10 min per month or.. less writing like a 15 word post on twitter or .. whatever social media they prefer just small updates letting us know whats going on. not asking for a essay or anything.. could just be like "We currently busy with dns0 eu so our work with next dns will slow donwn for a while" something simple like that would satesfy me and prolly alot of other ppl as well. cause its better knowing than just wondering forever not knowing anything

@nemchik
Copy link

nemchik commented Feb 2, 2024

https://github.com/nextdns/nextdns does not seem abandoned. I am not sure the status of this repository. It's possible different contributors responsible may not have visibility here vs the other repo that has a little more activity.

@ittairuf
Copy link

Hello @rs @romaincointepas, could you please check this?

@hagezi
Copy link
Contributor

hagezi commented Mar 23, 2024

@rs @romaincointepas could you at least give feedback to the community? Zero response for months. But it's not that difficult: yes, no, don't know would be enough.

@yokoffing If you don't get any feedback, just close the PR.

Gerd

@unknown4849
Copy link

https://help.nextdns.io/t/60yqxb9?r=m1y8n0m

and after ±6 month, got the answer.

@yokoffing
Copy link
Author

yokoffing commented Mar 26, 2024

https://help.nextdns.io/t/60yqxb9?r=m1y8n0m

We are only adding blocklists related to privacy, and our TI feeds include only source feeds. Hagezi TIF is an aggregation list that contains most of the same feeds as our TI feeds.

There are over 30 sources plus unique entries used in Hagezi's list that aren't in the NextDNS lists.

https://phishing-filter.pages.dev/phishing-filter-hosts.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/phishfort/phishfort-lists/master/blacklists/hotlist.json
https://phishing.army/download/phishing_army_blocklist_extended.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/durablenapkin/scamblocklist/master/hosts.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/jarelllama/Scam-Blocklist/main/lists/adblock/scams.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/scamsniffer/scam-database/main/blacklist/domains.json
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ShadowWhisperer/BlockLists/master/Lists/Scam
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/elliotwutingfeng/GlobalAntiScamOrg-blocklist/main/global-anti-scam-org-scam-urls-pihole.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/elliotwutingfeng/SpamdexingSites/main/blocklist.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/marco-acorte/antispam-it/main/antispam-it.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/matomo-org/referrer-spam-list/master/spammers.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hoshsadiq/adblock-nocoin-list/master/hosts.txt
https://hosts.tweedge.net/malicious.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bigdargon/hostsVN/master/extensions/threat/hosts
https://vn-badsite-filter.pages.dev/vn-badsite-filter-hosts.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/DandelionSprout/adfilt/master/Alternate%20versions%20Anti-Malware%20List/AntiMalwareAdGuardHome.txt
https://github.com/scafroglia93/blocklists
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/0xDanielLopez/TweetFeed/master/week.csv
https://botvrij.eu/data/ioclist.domain
https://dl.red.flag.domains/red.flag.domains.txt
https://lists.cyberhost.uk/malware.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/braveinnovators/ukrainian-security-filter/main/lists/domains.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/elliotwutingfeng/Inversion-DNSBL-Blocklists/main/Google_hostnames_Predecessor: Multi Light
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/elliotwutingfeng/Ukrainian-EMA-blocklist/main/urls-pihole.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iam-py-test/my_filters_001/main/Alternative%20list%20formats/antimalware_domains.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ttc-cert/TTC-CERT_blocklist_recommended/master/domain_blocklist_recommended.txt
https://threatview.io/Downloads/DOMAIN-High-Confidence-Feed.txt
https://zonefiles.io/f/compromised/domains/live/
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/uBlockOrigin/uAssets/master/filters/badware.txt
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AssoEchap/stalkerware-indicators/master/generated/hosts
https://filters.adavoid.org/ultimate-security-filter.txt

Not to mention, Hagezi removes entries for false positives and dead domains.

@wengkitttt
Copy link

I'm not an expert in this, but may I ask why it is so hard for them to add the Hagezi TIF list? Is it the format of the list? Or are there any policy issues that are stopping them?

I believe many NextDNS users want this list to be added, and some of their customers are leaving to go for other alternatives that have this list included, like AdGuardDNS, Controld, etc.

@DragonWolf5589
Copy link

DragonWolf5589 commented Mar 28, 2024

Wow an update after 6 months.. Now i know why hagazi removed nextdns as a recommended service and why everyone is moving to adguard and controlD instead as they allow the lists. Guess ill be doing the same after my paid nextdns ends and moving all my friends/family too. Especially as an autistic friend of mine keeps clicking dodgy links. But next dns tif list doesn't include the same protection as hagAzi TIF

@DragonWolf5589
Copy link

I'm not an expert in this, but may I ask why it is so hard for them to add the Hagezi TIF list? Is it the format of the list? Or are there any policy issues that are stopping them?

I believe many NextDNS users want this list to be added, and some of their customers are leaving to go for other alternatives that have this list included, like AdGuardDNS, Controld, etc.

All they said is "we only add privacy lists and use our own TIF"

Seems ill be joining everyone else leaving to another servicr once my paid year is up

@live4swell
Copy link

Wow an update after 6 months.. Now inonow what hagazi removed nexydns as a recommended service and why evwryone is moving to adguard and controlD instead. Guess ill be doing the same after my paid nextdns ends and moving all my friends/family too.

Does the service not work as intended? Do you have issues? I think those should be reasons for switching not silence from the company especially when things just work.

@unknown4849
Copy link

Does the service not work as intended? Do you have issues? I think those should be reasons for switching not silence from the company especially when things just work.

the services still working, so no need worry, but now they only at maintenace mode no update or new feature or remove outdate blocklist ( i mean maintain this github repo)

@xe-3
Copy link

xe-3 commented Apr 9, 2024

Does the service not work as intended? Do you have issues? I think those should be reasons for switching not silence from the company especially when things just work.

Most people aren't drawn to NextDNS because it "Just Works," features and customizability are what made NextDNS stand out. If your only concern is a DNS provider that just works their are many good options (including NextDNS). But don't be dismissive of other peoples' desire that their DNS service is actively maintained and continuing to improve and innovate and receive attention from the developers.

@PhoenixFossGR
Copy link

Please add this feature as it would be very beneficial. As paying NextDNS customers, we should be treated with a bit more respect and not being ignored.

@rs
Copy link

rs commented May 17, 2024

@rs rs closed this May 17, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

None yet