resource.Default()/etc is a footgun

[ash2k]

Problem Statement

opentelemetry-go/example/fib/main.go

Lines 45 to 53 in 69d0946

	r, _ := resource.Merge(
	resource.Default(),
	resource.NewWithAttributes(
	semconv.SchemaURL,
	semconv.ServiceName("fib"),
	semconv.ServiceVersion("v0.1.0"),
	attribute.String("environment", "demo"),
	),
	)

Code above gives an example of how to use resource.Default(). There is a problem with this code though - if you update otel dependencies you may get a cannot merge resource due to conflicting Schema URL error when running the code. This happens if otel SDK starts using a different version of the schema to what it used to use and what is used in the example/user code. I.e. schemas used to match but do not after SDK change. From user's perspective it all worked, but suddenly starts failing at runtime.

This is especially problematic if resource merging is conditional e.g. when it's only done when tracing is enabled. I've just had a situation where I bumped the otel dependencies, all tests passed, I cut a release and then it blew up when deployed to a canary environment where tracing is actually enabled.

It's not only resource.Default(), a few other methods in the resource package have the same issue.

Proposed Solution

Not sure. Approaches that are better than failing at runtime:

• Merging "just works" (somehow).
• Code fails to compile (somehow).

Alternatives

Prior Art

Additional Context

[ash2k]

Just added a unit test to my codebase and it fails:

import (
	"go.opentelemetry.io/otel/sdk/resource"
	semconv "go.opentelemetry.io/otel/semconv/v1.12.0"
)

func constructResource() (*resource.Resource, error) {
	return resource.Merge(
		resource.Default(),
		resource.NewWithAttributes(
			semconv.SchemaURL,
			semconv.ServiceNameKey.String("some name"),
			semconv.ServiceVersionKey.String("some ver"),
		),
	)
}

func TestConstructResource(t *testing.T) {
	_, err := constructResource()
	require.NoError(t, err)
}

        	Error:      	Received unexpected error:
        	            	cannot merge resource due to conflicting Schema URL
        	Test:       	TestConstructResource
--- FAIL: TestConstructResource (0.00s)

Fix is to change import to semconv "go.opentelemetry.io/otel/semconv/v1.17.0". This is not a good UX :)

[ash2k]

Perhaps those methods can be moved into the "versioned" packages? They can use the same underlying types, but a matching schema URL from that particular package. In the future more attributes can be added to new scema versions and having e.g. Default() in a versioned package expose that attribute only for a certain version would make sense. Put differently, today I cannot use those helper methods with older schema versions.

[Aneurysm9]

resource.Merge() does not have the schema translation capabilities it needs to make this work as intended. The schema module provides the schema parsing capabilities required to implement this. There is a collector schemaprocessor that is under construction that can demonstrate the use of that module. That said, implementing translation in resource.Merge() may be in violation of the resource specification.

[MrAlias]

Here's a new repo I created to handle schema translations: https://github.com/MrAlias/otel-schema-utils

Only thing supported currently is resource translations, but out of this it does provide a resource merge functionality that is schema URL aware: https://pkg.go.dev/github.com/MrAlias/otel-schema-utils@v0.1.0-alpha/schema#Converter.MergeResources

[pellared]

Closing as duplicate of #2341